← Semua picks

Tool Pick Conditional

Umami vs Plausible vs GoatCounter: privacy analytics pick for small dev teams

Three honest privacy analytics options — which one fits your team's budget, self-hosting tolerance, and actual data needs.

27 September 2026 · 7 menit ·Use case: Choosing a privacy-first analytics tool for Indonesian dev teams who need GDPR-safe tracking without the Google Analytics complexity or the Mixpanel price tag.
UmamiPlausibleGoatCounter

Three teams in the BSD City tech corridor asked me the same question last quarter: “We need to drop Google Analytics — what do we use instead?” Each team had different constraints. Here is what I actually recommended, and why.

Why privacy analytics matter more now

Indonesia’s UU PDP (Personal Data Protection Law) has been in enforcement mode since late 2024. It is not GDPR-equivalent in penalty severity yet, but the direction is clear: collecting personally identifiable data without a legal basis is a compliance risk. Google Analytics 4 with its cross-site tracking, fingerprinting, and US server storage sits awkwardly in this environment. More practically — cookie consent banners hurt conversion on mobile. Indonesian users dismiss them or bounce.

Privacy analytics tools solve both problems at once. No cookies, no consent required, no PII stored. The trade-off is less granular data. Whether that trade-off is acceptable depends on what your team actually does with analytics data day-to-day.

Comparison table

DimensionUmamiPlausibleGoatCounter
Hosted pricingFree tier (100k events), USD 9+/moUSD 9/mo (10k PV), no free tierFree up to 100k PV/mo
Self-hostingEasy (Docker, Postgres/MySQL)Harder (needs ClickHouse)Easy (single binary)
UI qualityClean, modernExcellent, polishedMinimal, functional
Custom eventsYesYes (limited on lower tiers)Basic
API accessFull REST APIFull REST APILimited
Tech stackNext.js + PrismaElixir + ClickHouseGo
VPS requirement (self-host)1GB RAM minimum2GB+ RAM (ClickHouse)256MB RAM
Script size~2KB~1KB~1.5KB
Bus factorCompany (Umami Software)CompanyOne developer

Umami

Strengths

Umami hits the right balance for most Indonesian dev teams. The dashboard is clean enough that a product manager at a startup in Alam Sutera can read it without a tutorial. You get pageviews, unique visitors, bounce rate, session duration, referrers, UTM parameters, and custom event tracking — everything a small team needs, nothing more.

Self-hosting is the real selling point. One docker-compose up and you have a running instance. PostgreSQL backend means you can run it on the same database server you already have. On a Rp150k/month VPS, Umami handles low-to-medium traffic sites without complaint. The data stays in your own infrastructure — relevant if you have clients who ask where their user data lives.

The REST API is solid. If you want to pull analytics data into an internal dashboard or a Slack bot that posts weekly stats, Umami’s API is well-documented and actually works.

Weaknesses

Umami’s custom events require a snippet of JavaScript to fire — not complicated, but it means you need developer involvement to track button clicks or checkout completions. Plausible’s approach is similar, so this is not unique to Umami, but worth noting if your team assumed “custom events = tag manager configuration.”

The hosted Umami Cloud free tier is 100k events per month. Events, not pageviews — every pageview counts as an event, and so does every custom event you fire. On a high-traffic marketing site with aggressive event tracking, this ceiling arrives faster than expected.

Plausible

Strengths

Plausible has the best out-of-box UI of the three. The dashboard is genuinely beautiful — something you can put on a TV screen in an office without embarrassment. It also has the smallest analytics script (~1KB), which matters if your Lighthouse score is someone’s KPI.

The funnels and goals UI (on paid plans) requires zero developer setup for basic conversion tracking. You define goals in the Plausible dashboard by URL pattern. This is the tool to pick when your analytics stakeholder is a non-technical founder or a performance marketing person who will not file a ticket to change tracking configuration.

Plausible also publishes detailed transparency reports about their infrastructure and business model. For teams working with European clients or any project that touches GDPR compliance conversations, Plausible’s reputation and documentation give you cover.

Weaknesses

No free tier on the hosted version. USD 9/month for 10k pageviews sounds cheap until your site grows — 100k pageviews is USD 19/month, 1M is USD 69/month. That is not expensive by SaaS standards, but for an Indonesian startup where the founder is watching every USD outflow, it is a recurring conversation.

Self-hosting Plausible Community Edition requires ClickHouse. ClickHouse is genuinely excellent for time-series analytics data, but it is not something you casually run on a 1GB VPS. You need at least 2GB RAM, and ClickHouse has operational quirks that will surprise a team that only knows PostgreSQL. If self-hosting is your goal, Umami or GoatCounter is easier.

GoatCounter

Strengths

GoatCounter is the most honest analytics tool of the three. The UI has zero decoration — just numbers in a sensible layout. It loads instantly. The hosted version is free up to 100k pageviews per month, which genuinely covers most personal projects and small sites.

The self-hosted version is a single Go binary. Drop it on a server, point it at a SQLite file, done. RAM requirement is negligible. If you have a Raspberry Pi or a leftover USD 3/month VPS gathering dust, GoatCounter will run on it.

For developer tools, documentation sites, or open-source project sites — where the audience is technical and you want to see which docs pages get traffic without spending a cent — GoatCounter is hard to argue against.

Weaknesses

The bus factor concern is real. GoatCounter is built and maintained by one person. Feature development is slow by design (this is a feature, not a bug, per the developer’s philosophy), but it means some things you might want — funnel tracking, deeper custom events, team access controls — are either missing or on a long roadmap. If the maintainer steps back, you are on your own with a self-hosted instance.

The UI that developers find refreshingly minimal is the same UI that confuses everyone else. Handing a GoatCounter dashboard URL to a client or a non-technical co-founder reliably generates support questions. Budget time for that.

Verdict

Pick Umami if:

  • You want to self-host with minimal operational overhead
  • Your team already runs PostgreSQL and does not want another database engine
  • You need a REST API for custom integrations
  • Non-technical stakeholders need to read the dashboard without training
  • Cost is the primary constraint — self-hosted Umami on an existing VPS is nearly free

Pick Plausible if:

  • You have a monthly SaaS budget and prefer managed hosting over ops work
  • The UI and dashboard polish matter (client demos, office screens, exec reporting)
  • You are working on a project with European data compliance requirements and want documented legal cover
  • Conversion funnel tracking without developer involvement is a priority

Pick GoatCounter if:

  • The project is a personal site, open-source project, or docs site with no budget
  • Your audience is developers who will not need a UI walkthrough
  • You want the smallest possible operational footprint
  • You are comfortable with the single-maintainer risk and find that trade-off acceptable

None of the three collect cookies. None require a consent banner. All three give you the pageview data you actually need for most product decisions. The choice comes down to who reads the dashboard, where you want to run it, and how much you are willing to pay for someone else to maintain the infrastructure.

For a two-person startup doing B2B SaaS: Umami self-hosted, PostgreSQL on the same VPS as your app, done in an afternoon. For a growth-stage company with a non-technical marketing lead: Plausible Cloud, no contest. For everything else: GoatCounter is free and it works.

Ditulis oleh Asti Larasati

// Pick Tool Pick lain


← Semua picks RSS feed